The first vinyl I bought that could be classified as 'punk' was London Calling. That's not earthshattering or even unusual for a midwestern white boy; but what I found hard to understand was the reaction of the friends I had at the time.
Largely limited to mainstream rock and heavy metal (we were in a fuckin suburb; what else?) I started to branch out in late high school, finding new energy in musicians like Elvis Costello, Devo, the B-52s and the Boomtown Rats; my HS friends could barely tolerate the Cars. I recall plaintively playing "Train In Vain" for one of these friends, trying to share the attraction I had for some different sounds, only to be met with a bemused, mostly tolerant look.
I have never understood this need to classify music. Ice-T once tried to defend his heavy band Body Count by saying "If you only listen to one type of music, you're fucked up" but I resist even the idea of music 'types'. I have argued over this incessantly with Zelmo (usually fueled by several beers); where are the lines? Iggy Pop was Punk before anybody ever though of it; but he wrote a song that was a hit for Bowie. Was there ever a more punk song than "My Generation"? Elvis Costello was once punk enough to get thrown off Saturday Night Live; now he collaborates with Burt Fuckin Bacharach. Blue Oyster Cult helped define metal, but have written some purely pop songs. The Clash were self-defined punks, but borrowed liberally from reggae, funk, old blues....
The Mekons started as art-school punks so DIY that they REFUSED to learn their instruments. But eventually, they blazed trails for alt-country, alternative, and indie rock, refusing to give a shit about their classification, instead following their own muses. Along the way, they did art shows, performance installations, wrote collaborative books, did a pioneering lesbian punk pirate musical, and hey! also become one of the longest running rock bands of ANY genre, remaining arguably more vital and interesting than other old timers like the Rolling Stones and the Eagles, recently incorporating English folk into their sound...
Music is a continuum. Pigeonhole all you want (and that is part of the misguided "marketing" that is helping to destroy large labels), but when it comes to the artists, the lines blur. Neil Young collaborates with Pearl Jam and tours with Sonic Youth.
This is odd. I noticed today that I have my Dad's fingers. Being a zombie, I guess I probably will not give them back.
I know, I ramble. But this thinking has been occasioned by a few listens to the new Green Day album, 21st Century Breakdown. It's a pretty mainstream release for me, I know, but bear with me....
I really loved their last album, American Idiot. The extended multi part songs, threaded with punk sing along choruses and shouted "hey!"s tripped my punky little zombie trigger, and had a bit of the PROG about them. It was a long way from songs about getting stoned, but it recalled the old days of bands like Husker Du and the Clash...
But that's not what I'm here to talk about. After a long period of work (5 years?) comes the followup, an honest to god I am not shitting you ROCK OPERA that should make Pete Townshend poop bricks and go back to drinking.
The release (does it even mean anything anymore to say 'album'? CD? This is a song series; I downloaded it; the constraints of 2 sides, or how much music you can fit on a CD, don't really mean much anymore...) is broken down into 3 acts, for want of a better word. "Heroes and Cons", "Charlatans and Saints", and "Horseshoes and Handgrenades". You can find more description elsewhere, I am not too worried about the story, such as it is, just now.
The release opens with a scratchy, tinny radio sounding intro, "Song Of The Century", which sounds like nothing so much as a piece of a mid-70s Queen snippet. I'm not kidding. But also, is it an accident that the song title checks The Ramones?
"21st Century Breakdown" is one of the longest pieces, and is the closest to something from american Idiot.
Born into Nixon I was raised in hellA welfare childWhere the teamsters dwelledThe last one bornThe first one to run
Holy, crap, am I the only one that reads that as a Springsteen reference? Also, look at this:
My generation is zeroI never made itAs a working class hero
The Who and John Lennon, in one triplet. It may not be poetry, but that is a fine weaving of cultural touchstones, that is. Wait, there's one more:
We are the desperate in the declineRaised by the bastards of 1969
Is that.. the Replacements? I would bet "Bastards of Young" is part of the DNA here...
Know Your Enemy has enough power chords and anthemic choruses to bring Joe Strummer back to life. And one of the prominent lines updates an old PIL song: Violence Is an energy. Just don't even try to tell me that is an accident.
Viva La Gloria. I can't see this as anything but a big old shout out to Patti Smith.
Before the Lobotomy. Not only a semi acoustic opening, but slamming chords and a nod to the Ramones? Holy shit. And the yell-along chorus:
Whiskey shots and cheap cigarettesWell I'm not stoned, I'm just fucked upI got so high, I can't stand upI'm not cursed cause I've been blessedI'm not in love cause I'm a mess
Last Night on Earth. Listen:
My beating heart belongs to youI walked for miles til I found youI'm here to honor youIf I lose everything in the fireDid I ever make it through?
Again and again the lyrics work around the ideas of resilience, of persistence, of insurmountable odds... this seems to me to be one of the central ones.
Also: East Jesus Nowhere. Regardless of the music and the lyrics. The title is just... classic.
Peacemaker is such a complete nod to Gogol Bordello, that if not Armstrong's singing you would never guess.... down to the hey hey! hey hey hey hey hey! It totally fuckin rocks. Even Shane McGowan would approve, if he could get off the floor.
Last Of The American Girls. Listen:
She plays her vinyl records singing songs on the eve of destructionShe's a sucker for all the criminals breaking the lawsShe will come in first for the end of western civilizationShe's and endless war like a hero for the lost causeLike a hurricane in the heart of devastation
was that a shout out to fuckin BARRY MCGUIRE? Okay, I'm a sucker for that song, and totally love that Grizzled taught it to one of Jennifer's lamblets, but holy hell, that is so fricking uncool... followed by a Judas Priest shoutout? Now this is getting ridiculous. But kind of fun, too, isn't it? Damn, I think so.
Murder City might as well be a Rancid song. what the hell, let's throw in some current references also, and make it a punkin gumbo.
followed by a reprise: Viva La Gloria? a pretty little song that slows things down a little bit. Holy shit, it's starting to feel paced, like a musical.
Restless Heart Syndrome would be a great Coldplay song. If it was done by Radiohead, even P-Fork would like it. As it is, it's better than either of those bands, but I predict will be disregarded because it was released by the guys who released an album named after poop.
One of the centerpieces is Horseshoes And Handgrenades, opening with a stomping boot sound like something from Stiff Little Fingers. But I'll tell you the guitars sound like the Figgs to me, and the lyrics do just as well... G-L-O-R-I-A shows up here, also, harking back to Patti, and U2, and Van Morrison...
21 Guns slows it right the hell down again, and it's about time. But it makes Armstrong reach for some high notes out of his range, and he makes them, apparently through sheer emotion. And I know it's probably just me, but I hear the echoes of the Alarm's 68 Guns in the background guitar lines...
Song of The Century is reprised... leading into American Eulogy, which has two parts. The first is Mass Hysteria, and the second is The Modern World. Thus the title of the post. In a seeming resonance to the Jam, the band recites " I don't wanna live in the Modern World, I don't wanna live in the Modern World..."
And finally, the band tries to reconcile with See The Light. What resonates: "I set a fire just to see the flame" When the world is senseless and heartless and uncaring, sometimes the individual acts are the ones that count.
As if to drive the fucking point home with a corked aluminum bat, the itunes release includes a cover of " A Quick One (while he's Away). You Are Forgiven, indeed. Green Day is not just wearing their influences on their sleeve on this one, they are weaving them into a tapestry of anger and emotion and energy that does the heritage proud.
You know, when you are young, unbridled energy and anger can be enough. The Rolling stones and the Replacements showed that, among others. But getting older adds ... weight. And you can try to ignore that, but it makes you look kind of stupid. Some people write the same songs over and over, and some get hairpieces, and some take viagra, but here's the thing: we all get old, we all are going to die, and that's what makes what we do now important and vital and sweet. Ignoring it is a dead end.
The major record labels have turned to WalMart for much of their hard copy distribution. especially since their own policies have driven non-corporate record stores and radio stations out of business.. Stupid MBA weasels... But WalMart wanted GD to remove the fukcs and the anti-religious rants; Green Day said no, they didn't give a shit. Who do you think will suffer more from that?
Some call Green Day punk, some punk-pop (usually saying that as if it's a bad thing), some just call 'em alternative.... To me it doesn't matter. If you listen to music based on the pigeonholes, I will guarantee you that you're missing out on something, somewhere, that you will like.
I refuse to restrict what I listen to because Pitchfork or somebody else calls it one thing or another. I will not discard something merely because it is popular. I refuse to stop looking for new sounds that make me shamble and lurch.
These guys have been listening to fucking EVERYTHING, and are not shy about making references in what they are writing. The Jam, the Clash, Springsteen, even enough Journey to make Zelmo happy;
"Hope I die before I get Old" "Better to burn out than it is to Rust" as Brando said recently, the irony is that the people who wrote those powerful lines are living long beyond some of their contemporaries. I would counter by saying the people who wrote those lines have never allowed themselves to rust, to get old.
I may be dead, but I don't have to be old.
I'm too tired to read all of this right now, but have to say, I LOVE that Elvis collaborated with Burt!!
ReplyDeleteI also remembering hearing the B-52's when I was in high school and thinking I had died and gone to heaven, but was also listening to a lot of 40's stuff at the time, 60's stuff, even freakish stuff (Ali Beirut and his Orientals). I have a Billy May, Cha Cha album that I will never part with!
I like what I like... don't care what it's called or if I should or shouldn't.
I'm too tired to read all of this right now,
ReplyDeletewell crap, who DOES have time to read it? I'm pretty fuckin longwinded for a dead guy...
I Love this post!! Sometimes it's like you are in my brainz. I think I may have to buy this new Green Day. Q101 is making me not want to, as they have the first single on a 30 minute rotation, but still, not GD's fault.
ReplyDeleteI have a mixed response to Green Day, but I always respect them.
ReplyDeleteBP, I just love this post. Love. It. You are so damn passionate about music! I just love that about you!
ReplyDeleteAnd I totally dig (man) you point about not categorizing things. What I don't get is that alot of the musicians I've heard interviewed seem to really respect each other. But, it's the fans who can be so closed-minded. And I think that really stinks.
I learned that watching Imus one morning years ago. He used to always have country music people on performing and then they'd sit around and talk for awhile. I've never been much of a country fan, but whoever was on this one morning (pretty well known but can't remember who) played his two songs. And then when they were gabbing, he said he had been influenced to write them by John Lennon. And they were for John Lennon. And I thought....if that guy can be so cool, I guess I should stop being so uncool in my thinking towards country music.
Anyway, I'm rambling. Just wanted to say that YOU ROCK!
ZRM indeed rocks - having listened to the new album, i kinda liked it(need to listen moar timez!), but the way you bring out all the influences(i did not catch them all) makes me like it even more
ReplyDeleteMost people feel the need to process large amounts of information into easily digested categories in order to simplify a complex world. It is a way to control their environment which can sometimes be a scary place. Unfortunately, if someone doesn't draw the lines first, individual data is swept up into broad categories, which over time are absorbed into even broader categories.
ReplyDeleteFor example, most people will simplify musical genres and forget the in-betweens. A musical touchstone of the 70’s becomes "punk rock" and that of the 90's is labeled "grunge rock". Since the music coming out of the 80's cannot be broadly identified, it is lumped into either "punk" or "grunge" - as if nothing really happened between the Sex Pistols and Nirvana. This does a disservice to a lot of bands like the Pixies, Sonic Youth, My Bloody Valentine, etc. who will then be lumped into one or the other pigeonholes.
Instead, by parsing the categories into tiny sub-categories, we can satisfy people's desire to place things in boxes, and still describe a particular sound with more accuracy. Therefore, the broad category of “metal” can be subdivided into death metal, speed metal, black metal, drone metal, etc. Perhaps this is too unwieldy, or merely unnecessary. But it is a lot more descriptive of the variety within the genre.
So, if you parse the genres fine enough, we can finally wind up with a multitude of genres, all consisting of exactly one band each....
ReplyDeleteIt's either useless or absurd, and it totally ignores the cross-pollination common amongst musicians, which is kind of what I'm getting at here.....
But then I won't be able to listen to synth-death-punk-clown-techno anymore...
ReplyDeleteI agree. Journey should no longer be labeled “Classic Rock” or “Stadium Rock” or “Crap Rock”. It should be appreciated for what it is - and that is “freakin' awesome”.
ReplyDeleteSteve Perry can eat a bowl of dicks.
ReplyDeleteZ-
ReplyDeleteHow about labeling them "pathetic has-beens"?
or maybe "Grandpa Rock"?
ReplyDeleteTsk, tsk, let's not start LABELING now.
ReplyDeleteTherefore you can include Journey with other great bands such as The Ramones, Sonic Youth, Styx, The Flaming Lips, Miles Davis, Genesis, Rush, Bee Gees, Radiohead, Lush, Beastie Boys, Nine Inch Nails, Wilco, Bauhaus, Pixies, Bay City Rollers, Spoon, Talking Heads, Pavement, De La Soul, Sigur Ros, Primus, Green Day, Rancid, Primal Scream, Mojo Nixon, Maynard Ferguson, The Carpenters, Jimmy Eat World, Air, Flatt & Scruggs, Suicidal Tendencies, Cibo Matto, Johnny Cash, Black Flag, Bad Brains, Tool, Fleetwood Mac, Ladytron, John Coltrane, Taking Back Sunday, M. Ward, Interpol, Jay-Z, ABBA, Os Mutantes, Earth, Wind and Fire, Orbital, B.B. King, The Clash, etc.
It's all just MUSIC after all.
...the Mekons....
ReplyDeletehey, tho, wotta playlist!
ReplyDeleteneeds some BOC though... maybe some Rush.
ReplyDeleteThat's my dream Summerfest lineup.
ReplyDeleteI guess I'll settle for Spoon.
Steve Perry can eat a bowl of dicks.
ReplyDeleteWould that be Super Sugar Dicks™ ?
umm, dood, some of those guys are deddzors...
ReplyDeleteNo problemo for a Zombie!
ReplyDeleteZelmo ignores my fuckin bloggo for weeks, then shows up one day with seven Journey-related comments, as if no time had elapsed.
ReplyDeleteWe noticed, guy, we noticed.
Say... AG was gone for quite some time too, and she just came back also.... Ya think?
Would it be irresponsible to speculate? It would be irresponsible NOT to.
The only irresponsibility would be to ignore the calendar....and realize that it is freakin' June which means it is freakin' Official Start of Summerfest Month.
ReplyDeleteLet's get our heads in the program people!
....also waiting on the 2009 Summerfest Blog.
ReplyDeleteBad newz dude. Not only is cash flow sketchy, and work load is onerous;
ReplyDeletebut the iWeb hosting is being hosed, and I haven't spent the time to figure out how to make the new arrangement work out.
Might be on the iffy side. Zorg can sleep a bit longer.